Narrative Text Analysis of Accident Reports with Tractors, Self-Propelled Harvesting Machinery and Materials Handling Machinery in Austrian Agriculture from 2008 to 2010 – A Comparison
More details
Hide details
University of Natural Ressources and Life Sciences. Division of Agricultural Engineering, Vienna, Austria
Ann Agric Environ Med. 2014;21(1):183–188
The aim of this study was the identification of accident scenarios and causes by analysing existing accident reports of recognized agricultural occupational accidents with tractors, self-propelled harvesting machinery and materials handling machinery from 2008 to 2010. As a result of a literature-based evaluation of past accident analyses, the narrative text analysis was chosen as an appropriate method. A narrative analysis of the text fields of accident reports that farmers used to report accidents to insurers was conducted to obtain detailed information about the scenarios and causes of accidents. This narrative analysis of reports was made the first time and yielded first insights for identifying antecedents of accidents and potential opportunities for technical based intervention. A literature and internet search was done to discuss and confirm the findings. The narrative text analysis showed that in more than one third of the accidents with tractors and materials handling machinery the vehicle rolled or tipped over. The most relevant accident scenarios with harvesting machinery were being trapped and falling down. The direct comparison of the analysed machinery categories showed that more than 10% of the accidents in each category were caused by technical faults, slippery or muddy terrain and incorrect or inappropriate operation of the vehicle. Accidents with tractors, harvesting machinery and materials handling machinery showed similarities in terms of causes, circumstances and consequences. Certain technical and communicative measures for accident prevention could be used for all three machinery categories. Nevertheless, some individual solutions for accident prevention, which suit each specific machine type, would be necessary.
Pickett W, Hartling L, Brison R, Guernsey J. Fatal work-related farm injuries in Canada, 1991–1995. Canadian Medical Association 1999. 1843–1848.
Day L. Farm work related fatalities among adults in Victoria, Australia – The human cost of agriculture. Accident Analysis and Prevention 1999; 31: 153–159.
Bunn T, Slavova S, Hall L. Narrative text analysis of Kentucky tractor fatality reports. Accident Analysis and Prevention 2008; 40: 419–425.
Thelin A. Fatal accidents in Swedish farming and forestry, 1988–1997. Safety Science 2002; 40: 501–517.
Mashadi B, Nasrolahi H. Automatic control of a modified tractor to work on steep side slopes. Journal of Terramechanics 2009; 46: 299–311.
Agricultural Fatalities in Canada 1990–2005. Canadian Agricultural Injury Surveillance Program, Ontario, Canada 2008. 5–19.
Horberry T, Larsson T, Johnston I, Lambert J. Forklift safety, traffic engineering and intelligent transport systems: a case study. Applied Ergonomics 2004; 35: 575–581.
Darcy C, Lovell M, Metcalfe J. Injuries from forklift trucks. Injury 1995; 26(4): 285.
Sicher Auf- und Absteigen bei Erntemaschinen. Land- und forstwirtschaftlichen Sozialversicherungsträger Franken und Oberbayern, fobpm2010–53.pdf (access: 2012.03.02).
Huber A. Fahrzeugstürze im Berggebiet – Unfallgeschehen. Landtechnik im Alpenraum – ART-Schriftenreihe 12, http://www. komplett.pdf (access: 2012.04.02).
Mayrhofer H, Quendler E, Boxberger J. Analysis of accidents with self-propelled agricultural machines from 2008 to 2010 in Austria. International Conference RAGUSA SHWA; Sept 3–6 2012; Ragusa.
McKenzie J, Scott D, Campbell M, McClure R. The use of narrative text for injury surveillance research: A systematic review. Journal of Accident Analysis and Prevention 2010; 42: 354–363.
Lincoln A, Sorock G, Courtney T, Wellman H, Smith G, Amoroso P. Using narrative text and coded data to develop hazard scenarios for occupational injury interventions. Inj. Prev. 2004; 10: 249–254.
Agricultural Fatalities and Hospitalizations in Ontario 1990–2004. Canadian Agricultural Injury Surveillance Program, Ontario, Canada 2007. 4–48.
Coury GH, Kumar S, Jones E. Farm related injuries and fatalities in Alberta. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 1999; 23: 539–547.
Suutarinen J. Tractor accidents and their prevention. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 1992; 10(4): 321–329.
Gerberich S, Gibson R, French L, Lee T, Carr W, Kochevar L et al. Machinery-related injuries: regional rural injury study-I. Journal of Accident Analysis and Prevention 1998; 30(6): 793–804.
Goodman R, Smith J, Sikes R, Rogers D, Mickey J. Fatalities associated with farm tractor injuries – an epidemiologic study. Public Health Rep. 1985; 100: 329–333.
Collins J, Landen D, Kisner S, Johnston J, Chin S, Kennedy R. Fatal occupational injuries associated with forklifts, United States, 1980– 1994. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 1999; 36 (5): 504–512.
Hoppe U, Meyer H. Ursachen von Traktorunfällen. Landtechnik 2005; 2: 90–91.